One theme among many in the 2026 midterm election was “the return of a religious left,” as progressive reporter Ezra Klein celebrated. Klein posted a clip from an interview he conducted with Senator-elect James Talarico (D-Texas), in which Talarico characteristically leaned into religious language. As Christopher Scalia noted wryly, “If, say, Ted Cruz made similar remarks, we’d be warned that he was taking a wrecking ball to the wall separating church and state.”

Talarico Interview

Talarico began by noting the obvious. “You read ‘Common Sense’ by Thomas Paine, you read Lincoln’s speeches, you listen to Fannie Lou Hamer, you read Dr. [Martin Luther] King, [Jr.] — they infused their politics with a moral foundation, oftentimes explicitly rooted in faith,” he stated. “What we’re suffering from now [is]: people start with their politics and then try to figure out the morality on top of that, when it should be reversed.”

Talarico added, “I really do feel like this is a way that I can love my neighbor at scale, through good public policy.” Christians across the political spectrum could affirm that statement; they only differ over what policies best love their neighbors.

But then Talarico went further. “If we can infuse our politics with more of this spirituality, we could treat politics like a sacrament,” he declared. “We could have an incarnational politics.”

Understandably, Klein interjected, “What does that mean?”

Before he could answer, Talarico had to set the boundaries for this “incarnational politics,” which prompted a less understandable interjection.

Talarico: “You don’t have to be a Christian. You don’t even have to be part of an organized religion. I do think that everyone is religious.”
Klein: “Ooh, that’s a bold claim. What do you mean by that?”
Talarico: “I think we all put our trust in something. … I choose to put my faith in love, which sometimes, the evidence suggests, is not going to work. Sometimes love is defeated. Sometimes love experiences setbacks. But the trust is that it will one day win. And that’s what my tradition is all about.”

Klein’s surprise showed his secular biases, and Talarico gave the straightforward explanation that everyone believes in something; humans are by nature religious creatures. Amid that conversational dynamic, Talarico defined his background: to participate in his “incarnational politics,” a person need not be a Christian, nor even a part of any organized religion; they simply must believe in love, as Talarico does. Here, “love” is given no further definition.

Finally, Talarico could define the substance of his “incarnational politics”: “If you do believe that each person is sacred, that each person is holy, that each person bears the divine image, that should fundamentally change how we engage in politics, how we treat our neighbors, and how we treat our enemies. To me, an incarnational politics would take seriously the idea that every person is … is God.”

That conclusion is startling — and more so given the preceding pause. Talarico’s words could be interpreted in a pantheistic sense, that everyone participates in an impersonal deistic force filling all things. But his words could also be a reference to the Parable of the Sheep and the Goats, a favorite among liberal Christians. Jesus welcomes the sheep into heaven, “For I was hungry and you gave me food, I was thirsty and you gave me drink, I was a stranger and you welcomed me, I was naked and you clothed me, I was sick and you visited me, I was in prison and you came to me. … as you did it to one of the least of these my brothers, you did it to me” (Matthew 25:35-36, 40).

Regardless, in the two-minute clip, Talarico displays some of the classic hallmarks of liberal Christian theology. He de-emphasizes the difference between Christianity and other religions. He speaks of God in vague terms that could either express Christian ideas or pantheistic ones. He articulates a creed that consists almost entirely of love. And he ties religious activity to political action.

What Is Liberal Christianity?

These claims are important enough to receive more explanation than a bare assertion, especially as many TWS readers are likely unfamiliar with liberal Christianity except at a distance.

Friedrich Schleiermacher

The movement began in 19th-century Germany, where an academic named Friedrich Schleiermacher (1768-1834) sought to rescue Christianity from the assaults of higher criticism by removing it from the skeptical scrutiny of higher critics. Unfortunately, what Schleiermacher rescued bore little relation to historical Christianity. Some might say he threw out the baby with the bathwater; more accurately, he scooped up a pail of filthy water and left the baby behind.

For Schleiermacher, Christianity — or indeed any religion — was neither truth nor ethics but merely feeling. “Religion … resigns, at once, all claims on anything that belongs either to science or morality. … Ideas and principles are all foreign to religion,” he maintained. “Piety cannot be an instinct craving for a mess of metaphysical and ethical crumbs” (“On Religion: Speeches to Its Cultured Despisers,” Speech 2).

Schleiermacher defined religion as “this sense for the infinite,” and he argued that “every original and new communication of the Universe to man is a revelation …. Every intuition and every original feeling proceeds from revelation.” This understanding of religion leans decidedly more towards pantheism than to the personal, knowable God of Scripture.

Schleiermacher’s understanding of religion even cuts off faith and doctrine. “So far is it [belief] from being the highest in religion, as is asserted, that it must be rejected by all who would force their way into the sanctuary of religion.”

What, then, is doctrine? “Christian doctrines are accounts of the Christian religious affections set forth in speech” (“The Christian Faith”). Again, he wrote, “The self-identical essence of piety is this: the consciousness of being absolutely dependent or, which is the same thing, of being in relation with God.” For Schleiermacher, religious doctrines are not truth claims about reality, but expressions of the theologian’s religious feelings — specifically his feelings of absolute dependence, although the object of this dependence is inherently unknowable.

To the reader who thinks this theology hails from the “Twilight Zone,” you are not alone. Schleiermacher redefined theology not as the study of God, but as the study of man’s opinions and feelings about God. Instead of refuting higher criticism’s rejection of scriptural authority and any supernatural intervention in history, Schleiermacher surrendered the entire field and attempted to salvage whatever mongrel religion remained.

Rudolf Bultmann

A later liberal theologian articulated the implications of this sea change. Rudolf Bultmann (1884-1976) set out on a quest to “demythologize” Christian doctrine. Like Schleiermacher, Bultmann understood his subject to cover human self-understanding, not objective truth. “The real point of myth is not to present an objective picture,” he said, but rather to present “how we human beings understand ourselves in our world” (“New Testament and Mythology”).

For liberal Christianity, “our world” became the focus instead of the world of the Scriptures. “To demythologize is to reject not Scripture or the Christian message as a whole, but the world-view of Scripture, which is the world-view of a past epoch,” Bultmann wrote. “Demythologizing takes the modern world-view as a criterion” (“Jesus Christ and Mythology”).

Liberal Christians tried to harmonize Christianity with cultural ideas. In practice, this meant that they took cultural ideas as their starting point and shed whatever elements of Christianity did not agree. The same process is evident in liberal denominations today, which have adopted the culture’s view of, for instance, sexuality and gender, to the rejection of a biblical worldview.

Adolf von Harnack

Yet liberal Christians could identify the cultural faults of other generations better than their own. Liberal church historian Adolf von Harnack (1851-1930) argued that, over centuries, standard church orthodoxy had imported ideas from Greek philosophy that distorted the gospel, and that liberal Christians were the ones reclaiming its primitive form.

“Christendom became more and more penetrated by the Greek and philosophical idea that true religion is first and foremost ‘doctrine,’” von Harnack taught. “There are only two possibilities here: either the Gospel is in all respects identical with its earliest form, in which case it came with its time and has departed with it; or else it contains something which, under differing historical forms, is of permanent validity. The latter is the true view” (“What is Christianity?”).

Notice again how von Harnack believed he was rescuing Christianity from historical irrelevance, while in fact he was the one who rejected the timeless message of the gospel as irrelevant. Roman Catholic theologian George Tyrrell, a contemporary of von Harnack, criticized him. “The Christ that Harnack sees, looking back through nineteen centuries of Catholic darkness, is only the reflection of a Liberal Protestant face, seen at the bottom of a deep well.”

So, what was the message of Christianity, according to 19th-century liberalism? Conservative opponent J. Gresham Machen (1881-1937) summed it up in two points: “the universal fatherhood of God and the universal brotherhood of man” (“Christianity and Liberalism”). Liberals thought of themselves as “kinder, gentler” Christianity. Their view of God as father of all neglected his holy wrath against sin. Their view of universal brotherhood stressed social acts of benevolence over individual acts of repentance.

Von Harnack distilled his understanding of Christianity in this way: “To our modern way of thinking and feeling, Christ’s message appears in the clearest and most direct light when grasped in connection with the idea of God the Father and the infinite value of the human soul.” The reader may hear an echo of this in Talarico’s assertion “that each person is sacred, that each person is holy, that each person bears the divine image.”

A Different Religion

Conservatives like Machen were appalled at this new doctrine, with Machen going so far as to argue that liberalism was an entirely different religion. “The two religions are different with regard to the presuppositions of the Christian message, the view of God and the view of man; and they are also different with regard to their estimate of the Book in which the message is contained. … They differ fundamentally with regard to the message itself.” Even regarding Jesus Christ, “liberalism regards Jesus as the fairest flower of humanity; Christianity regards Him as a supernatural Person. … The difference between those two views is the difference between two totally diverse religions.”

Christians ignore Machen’s warning at their peril. Whenever any person or group tries to bridge the divide and find unity between the two diametrically opposed systems, it is always biblical Christianity that is forced to compromise.

Later Developments in Liberal Christianity

It’s worth noting how liberal Christianity itself continued to change after the 19th century.

The de-emphasis on doctrine naturally oriented liberal Christianity toward social action. In 1917, American liberal Walter Rauschenbusch (1861-1918) called for a “social gospel” that “plainly concentrates religious interest on the great ethical problems of social life. … The non-ethical practices and beliefs in historical Christianity nearly all centre on the winning of heaven and immortality. On the other hand, the Kingdom of God can be established by nothing except righteous life and action” (“A Theology for the Social Gospel”).

This social gospel proclaimed a message of salvation not through individual repentance of sins but through collective undoing of social wrongs. “The individualistic gospel has taught us to see the sinfulness of every human heart and has inspired us with faith in the willingness and power of God to save every soul that comes to him,” wrote Rauschenbusch. “But it has not given us an adequate understanding of the sinfulness of the social order and its share in the sins of all individuals within it. It has not evoked faith in the will and power of God to redeem the permanent institutions of human society from their inherited guilt of oppression and extortion. … The social gospel seeks to bring men under repentance for their collective sins and to create a more sensitive and more modern conscience.”

It takes little imagination to see how such a theology would readily ally itself with Marxist critical theory and social activism.

Liberal Christianity’s cultural osmosis with an increasingly pluralistic society also enticed it to disavow the exclusivity of Christianity. In 1975, English liberal John Hick called for a “needed Copernican revolution in theology” that “involves an equally radical transformation in our conception of the universe of faiths and the place of our own religion within it.”

He endorsed “a shift from the dogma that Christianity is at the centre to the realization that it is God who is at the centre, and that all the religions of mankind, including our own, serve and revolve around him” (“God and the Universe of Faiths”). Hick’s views were shaped by his work among Muslim immigrants in Birmingham, England.

Both Hamilton and Talarico have publicly rejected the exclusivity of Christianity.

Historical Perspective

It’s worth noting the timeline of this liberal movement coming to America. As readers may have detected, the liberal scholars cited above all lived in Germany, a center of Enlightenment ideas and higher criticism in the 19th century. It took time for this new brand of Christianity to permeate throughout Europe and then across the Atlantic. Indeed, during much of Schleiermacher’s career, the United States was enjoying an unprecedented outpouring of the Holy Spirit in the Second Great Awakening.

Only towards the end of the 19th century did liberalism begin to gain ascendancy in American denominations. By the 1920s, Machen and other fundamentalists were forced out of Princeton Seminary and ultimately left the Presbyterian Church (PCUSA) to form the conservative Orthodox Presbyterian Church (OPC). The Progressive Era marked a turning point to the dominance of liberal Christianity in American public life.

Nevertheless, it would not do justice to history to mark the late 19th century as the beginning of liberal Christianity in America. By the early 1700s, Congregationalist churches in Boston had already drifted from orthodoxy over their discomfort at the wrath of God and rationalist denial of the Trinity. In response, orthodox Christians left Harvard to found Yale Seminary, where Jonathan Edwards was trained. Edwards strove against the Bostonian opponents of the First Great Awakening, and he died while helping to launch what would become Princeton Seminary because Yale had already become too liberal.

Boston Congregationalists eventually drifted into Universalism and Unitarianism — originally two distinct heresies whose remnants merged into one denomination in the 20th century. By then, the merger felt natural. Like the liberal Christianity imported from European universities, both groups derived their ideas by elevating the authority of human reason above that of Scripture. This simply meant they imported cultural ideas and looked more like the culture than the church.

Thus, liberal strands of Christianity were present in the United States even before independence, and they have exercised political influence throughout that period. (For example, former President John Adams wrote in 1816 that he had been a Unitarian “for more than Sixty Years” and expressed an attraction to universalist ideas.)

This historical perspective raises the question: if liberal Christianity has always been in Washington, then what is new about the candidates elected in 2026?

In an absolute sense, neither the religious nor political convictions of newly elected legislators like James Talarico or Adam Hamilton is entirely new. But the element gaining widespread attention is the fervor and force with which they marshal religious arguments from the Bible to support their policy prescriptions.

Liberal Christians used to make such arguments regularly. In a famous example from 1896, liberal Christian and repeat presidential nominee William Jennings Bryan excoriated the gold standard, “You shall not press down upon the brow of labor this crown of thorns. You shall not crucify mankind upon a cross of gold.”

But one feature of liberal Christianity is that it takes its cues from the culture. As American culture became more secular, and as Americans became more biblically illiterate, liberal appeals to Scripture waned. When evangelicals reengaged politically in the late 20th century, they had the Bible references all to themselves. Liberals are belatedly realizing the rhetorical power of Scripture and are choosing candidates who can use its idiom.

Theological Perspective

What is the theological significance of liberal Christianity? The answer to that question reveals a person’s priorities. A liberal Christian would answer, “It provides ready motivation for social change, which can save many people here and now from poverty, ignorance, violence, and war.” An orthodox Christian would answer, it retrains man’s gaze from his eternal state, obscuring the fact that he most needs salvation from the wrath of God for his sins. The ultimate conflict is over what it is from which man needs to be saved.

In 1937, H. Richard Niebuhr summarized the doctrine of liberal Christianity thus, “A God without wrath brought men without sin into a kingdom without judgment through the ministrations of a Christ without a cross.” In the first century, Paul warned the Galatian churches tempted to succumb to the Judaizers, “There are some who trouble you and want to distort the gospel of Christ. But even if we or an angel from heaven should preach to you a gospel contrary to the one we preached to you, let him be accursed” (Galatians 1:7-8).

There is only one Christian message that can bring real salvation. “The liberal Jesus, despite all the efforts of modern psychological reconstruction to galvanize Him into life, remains a manufactured figure of the stage,” wrote Machen. “The Jesus of the New Testament has at least one advantage over the Jesus of modern reconstruction — He is real. He is not a manufactured figure suitable as a point of support for ethical maxims, but a genuine Person whom a man can love. Men have loved Him through all the Christian centuries. And the strange thing is that, despite all the efforts to remove Him from the pages of history, there are those who love Him still.”

This article was written by Joshua Arnold and origianlly published on The Washington Stand. For more content like this, visit Real Life Network.